Stop Focusing on Fixing Women

Stop Focusing on Fixing Women

When considering your organisation’s 2023 plans, perhaps ANOTHER Women in Leadership program is not the answer.

The solution to gender diversity problems is not to ‘fix women’ but rather to fix the flawed criteria and crooked systems that continue to impede many women’s access to power.

I find it incredible how organisations can run Women in Leadership programs for years and years, and have generation after generation of women leaders raise the same systemic issues (or in some instances worsening issues).

Yet, these organisations continue to think that the solution is another ‘Women in Leadership’ program.

If you want to consider a better way forward, perhaps consider who else needs to be developed.

Bloke Coaching is a program that helps everyone to understand male privilege, patriarchy and prejudice, and work proactively to address the barriers encountered by women and other genders which perpetuate inequalities.

Maybe it’s time to shake things up.

Mansplaining Flowchart by Kim Goodwin

Lesson 3 – What to do mid-mansplain

Always when explaining anything, look out for cues from the other person/people.

👉 High frequency (polite) nodding

👉 Noone is writing anything down; perhaps fiddling with their pen

👉 No further comments or questions; conversation has become a monologue

👉 Uncomfortable silence after you have finished speaking

👉 Pursed lips and ‘biting

👉 You are asking yourself questions and answering them

👉 someone has attempted to interject but you have continued to talk over the top of them

👉 Others avoid direct eye contact with you

👉 Others have begun to look at each other or stare at their notebooks or intensely at your slides.

👉 Others encourage the topic to be changed or attempt a redirect.

If one or more of the above are present, perhaps it’s time to pause and double-check if other people need you to continue.

Perhaps try one of the following:

🔉 “Just checking, do you need me to go into this further?”

🔉 “Just checking, how comfortable are you already with what I’m going into?”

🔉 “Just checking, who would like me to explain this?”

🔉 “Just checking, who else has something to add?”

🔉 “Just checking, do you need this level of detail from me?”

We can all unconsciously (or accidentally) become a mansplainer.

However it’s when we are mid-mansplain, and we choose to ignore the signals other people are sending us and continue our course of action, that we are wholly deserving of the labelling.

We can be better than that.

👇Use the comments to share other signs that would-be-mansplainers should look out for.

How to NOT to Mansplain – In 3 Easy Lessons

How to NOT to Mansplain – In 3 Easy Lessons

Lesson 1 – You Don’t know as much as you think you do

There is a tendency that the less we know about a topic, the more we overestimate our own knowledge or competence with that topic.

There’s a name for it – the Dunning-Kruger Effect.

It’s a thing. Now you know. So don’t be that person.

Remaining silent and listening to others is a perfectly ok thing to do.

 

Lesson 2 – Ask yourself, are you Mansplaining?

Print the below flowchart. (Flowchart Credit: Kim Goodman)

Paste it at the back of your notebook or pin it next to your monitor.

Refer to it in order to test assumptions you may be making.

Extension: Check in throughout the conversation about some of those assumptions. Eg. Perhaps you have been asked to explain one thing but check in again before you start explaining more than that particular thing.

It’s not too difficult. You can do it.

Mansplaining Flowchart by Kim Goodwin

Lesson 3 – What to do mid-mansplain

Always when explaining anything, look out for cues from the other person/people.

👉 High frequency (polite) nodding

👉 Noone is writing anything down; perhaps fiddling with their pen

👉 No further comments or questions; conversation has become a monologue

👉 Uncomfortable silence after you have finished speaking

👉 Pursed lips and ‘biting

👉 You are asking yourself questions and answering them

👉 someone has attempted to interject but you have continued to talk over the top of them

👉 Others avoid direct eye contact with you

👉 Others have begun to look at each other or stare at their notebooks or intensely at your slides.

👉 Others encourage the topic to be changed or attempt a redirect.

If one or more of the above are present, perhaps it’s time to pause and double-check if other people need you to continue.

Perhaps try one of the following:

🔉 “Just checking, do you need me to go into this further?”

🔉 “Just checking, how comfortable are you already with what I’m going into?”

🔉 “Just checking, who would like me to explain this?”

🔉 “Just checking, who else has something to add?”

🔉 “Just checking, do you need this level of detail from me?”

We can all unconsciously (or accidentally) become a mansplainer.

However it’s when we are mid-mansplain, and we choose to ignore the signals other people are sending us and continue our course of action, that we are wholly deserving of the labelling.

We can be better than that.

👇Use the comments to share other signs that would-be-mansplainers should look out for.

Are you watering down your DEI Initatives?

Are you watering down your DEI Initatives?

𝗔𝗿𝗲 𝘆𝗼𝘂 𝘄𝗮𝘁𝗲𝗿𝗶𝗻𝗴 𝗱𝗼𝘄𝗻 𝘆𝗼𝘂𝗿 𝗗𝗘𝗜 𝗶𝗻𝗶𝘁𝗶𝗮𝘁𝗶𝘃𝗲𝘀?

There is a difference between compliance training and real development.

I don’t work in compliance training, but unfortunately, many organisations mistake DEI as another compliance topic.

At the heart, many organisations want to be seen to be tackling the issue and are looking for options that can tick boxes.

Unconscious Bias Training has become a go-to option for organisations wanting more than just EEO and anti-discrimination modules, but in reality, it is not doing what you think it is doing.

Whilst Unconscious Bias is now a fairly well-known term, very few people take any meaningful steps.

Most people think ‘greater awareness’ is a suitable outcome or takeaway, without actually challenging what this awareness is or how it will inform their actions going forward.

The training ticks a box. And then people wonder why it hasn’t produced any meaningful change.

We may have crossed our arms, and committed to #breakthebias2022, for International Women’s Day 2022, but how has that been going for you?

We get kudos for showing up. We applaud commitments to champion change.

That’s the end of the story.

Next time, pay attention to the subtle use of words used by a program sponsor or a senior leader that has been through unconscious bias training.

“WE need to address this” or “WE need to do more about this.” or something similar…

Whilst sharing accountability through ‘WE’ (and getting everyone’s heads nodding) it actually also serves to negate personal responsibility.

Which means nothing changes.

Better leadership looks like:

“I am going to fix the problem by….”

“I am going to change the way… “

“I know that I’ve been getting it wrong”.

Unfortunately, we often fall into the trap of thinking it is other people’s biases that we need to break.

This mindset leaves us to overlook our own prejudices.

This mindset evades the uncomfortable truth that we are contributing to the problem.

Some more than others.

Our discomfort is worth others feeling more comfortable.

Discomfort is where learning happens.

Discomfort motivates real change.

You don’t need more unconscious bias training.

We don’t need more slides or e-learning.

We need a better intervention.

#blokecoaching is an uncomfortable program.

And we make no apologies for that.

Clients get upset.

They cry. They argue.

Through the program, we help everyone to understand their privilege, the patriarchal system and their individual prejudices, and those topics are going to stir up some big feelings.

But that is part of the process. And our clients are better for it.

Transgender Awareness Week 2022

Transgender Awareness Week 2022

Just a reminder that Transgender Awareness Week should be about giving visibility to the challenges faced by this community – issues of prejudice, discrimination, and violence that affect the transgender community – and working to ensure greater inclusion of members of this community within your organisation.

Don’t take ‘visibility’ as an invitation to push people who are members of the transgender community into the spotlight as a way of signalling inclusion, and acceptance.

It is not the role of members of this community to educate us (unless that is specifically a role they have chosen to take up) and answer questions that we have or to be an expert on diversity and inclusion policies and practices. Or to be a spokesperson for all of the experiences of the people of this community.

Their experience is their own, and their right to share or keep it private.

We need to educate ourselves.

➡️ Reflect on whether our discussions about gender equality are cis-centric, binary or lacking intersectionality. And what we could be doing better to support all genders? Take a look at whether your inclusion policies tend to focus on the LGB and not so much the TQ+.

➡️ Reflect on our language, particularly how we talk about people of this community, particularly when in the company of only cis people. Is our language affirming of gender or treating ‘them’ as an ‘other’ or ‘special’?

➡️ Reflect on whether our ‘curiosity’ to understand things we haven’t experienced personally, leads us to ask inappropriate questions or pry into details of someone’s life that they should not feel pressured to disclose to us (ever). Would we ask the same questions to someone who is cis?

➡️ Reflect on whether our network (professional and personal) or workplace includes members of this community and if there are none (or you can count them on one hand), reflect on what may be contributing to that. Reflect on what we could do to become more inclusive and improve the diversity of friends, network or workplace.

➡️ Reflect on aspects of the cis-tem (system) that may be contributing to the exclusion or uncomfortableness of members of this community. Take a more conscious look at our bathroom setup, pronoun usage, dress codes, and what level of support and sensitivity is given to employees undertaking a gender affirmation process.

That’s what I think it is supposed to be about.

My Hands Are Full

My Hands Are Full

For the last 18 months, I’ve been, and still am, the primary carer for my daughter on at least two days of the working week (plus Sunday).

My wife and I have split responsibilities so that we both do paid work 3 days a week, 3 days a week we are the primary carer for the kids (we have 3), and Saturdays we are all together.

It is not easy to coordinate. And starting and running a business during this time has been particularly challenging.

Both of us realise though that the person looking after the kids on a particular day will, on balance, usually have the tougher day, and needs the ‘hunter/gatherer’s support from the moment they have finished ‘gathering’ for the day.

This is a promise we make to each other, and we try our best to leave our other work at work so that we can be there for the other person.

Personally, I have found it particularly difficult to manage my own expectations of what I can commit to regarding my business.

I’ve been thinking “I only work 3 days”.

Through coaching, I realised that that simple phrase was actually making me feel inadequate. An unconscious narrative that I should be working 5 days in my business, and was subsequently putting pressure on myself to make up the other 2 days outside of standard hours.

I wasn’t logging off, and I was trying to do work when my daughter slept or was otherwise distracted. I was working at night when everyone slept (and I should have been sleeping too).

I then transitioned to thinking “Actually, I work 3 days”. And realised that I needed to contain my work commitments to these days. Having this bleed into home life, wasn’t an option.

But again, through coaching, I began to appreciate that I was still actually devaluing my domestic/caring duties because they weren’t ‘paid’. I still felt the pressure to think about work, when I wasn’t at work. And my other job suffered.

Despite my recognition that caring responsibilities are, actually, the harder job.

The reality is “I’m working 7 days. I have 2 jobs.”

My new personal narrative is that “I’m a father and husband first. My second job is as a business owner, coach and facilitator.”

And, with this in mind, and looking back at the last couple of years (which admittedly have been the hardest of my life), I’ve never been happier.

AND, I think I’m better at being a gatherer.

There is a lot of pressure that we, and society, place on ourselves to be the hunter/gatherer, and to be the best hunter/gatherer.

The difficult lesson I’ve learnt this year is that we should instead perhaps focus on being the best partner and father first (or whatever this other ‘job’ is for you).

In the scheme of things, no one really cares how good of a hunter you are. But the important people care about how good you are at your first job.